Soohey played Women’s Basketball and Softball at CM before graduating in 2014 with High Honors. While in the Mustang basketball uniform Soohey was named 1st Team All-Conference, 1st Team All-American, and earned Academic All-Conference and Academic All-American Honors in both basketball and softball. Soohey was also awarded the prestigous CMCC Female Athlete of the Year in 2015. After completing her graduation requirements at CM, Soohey earned a basketball scholarship to play at Rochester College (MI). She also earned Academic All-American honors while at RC. In high school, Soohey was a 4-year varsity softball and basketball player for Lincoln Academy where she earned KVAC 2nd Team All-Conference honors.